When it comes to home or business security, understanding your options can save you money and provide peace of mind. Many property owners in Bellmore, NY face the same dilemma: should you rekey your existing locks or replace them entirely? As a family owned operated locksmith company serving Long Island for years, we've helped countless residential and commercial customers make this decision. The answer typically depends on your specific situation, budget, and security needs. Let's explore both options so you can make the best choice for your property.
Understanding the Rekeying Process
Rekeying is a cost-effective solution that allows you to keep your existing lock hardware while creating new key access. During the rekey process, our certified company professionals disassemble the lock cylinder and replace the internal components—specifically the pins and springs—so the original key no longer works. This service is perfect when you want to maintain your current door hardware but need to change who has access.
The process involves:
- Removing the lock cylinder from the doorknob or deadbolt
- Disassembling the internal pin mechanism
- Installing new pins that match a different key configuration
- Testing to ensure the new key works smoothly
- Reassembling everything without changing the exterior appearance
When Rekeying Makes Sense
Choosing to rekey is the smart solution in several common scenarios. If you've recently moved into a new home in Bellmore, NY, rekeying ensures that previous owners, contractors, or anyone with the old key can no longer access your property. This is a fundamental security rule that every homeowner should follow.
Other situations where rekeying is ideal include:
- Lost or stolen keys: When keys go missing, rekeying provides immediate security
- After a lockout: Once we help you regain entry, consider rekeying for peace of mind
- Broken key situations: If a key breaks in the lock, we can extract it and rekey simultaneously
- Employee turnover: Commercial business owners should rekey when staff members leave
- Tenant changes: Residential landlords need fresh keys between occupants
- Relationship changes: Divorce or separation often requires limiting access
- Master key systems: Create a more organized key system for multiple doors
Complete Lock Replacement: When It's Necessary
While rekeying handles many situations, sometimes full lock replacement is the better choice. Lock replacement means removing your existing hardware entirely and installing new lock components. This service becomes necessary when locks are damaged, outdated, or simply can't provide the security level you need.
Consider changing locks completely when:
- Locks are worn, damaged, or malfunctioning after years of use
- You want to upgrade to premium, high-security lock systems
- Current locks don't meet modern security standards
- Lock mechanisms are broken beyond simple repair
- You're renovating and want updated door hardware aesthetics
- Locks have been tampered with or damaged during a break-in attempt
- You need specialized commercial-grade security for your business
- Integration with smart home or auto-lock systems is desired
Cost Comparison: Making the Budget-Friendly Choice
Understanding the cost difference between these two services helps you make an informed decision. Rekeying is almost always more economical because it preserves your existing lock hardware. You're only paying for the locksmith's labor and new pin components.
Key cost factors to consider:
- Rekeying costs: Generally affordable, with prices varying based on the number of locks
- Replacement costs: Higher due to new hardware plus installation labor
- Trip fees: Our mobile service includes travel to your Bellmore, NY location
- Emergency vs. standard hours: After-hours emergency service may differ in pricing
- Multiple locks: Many locksmiths offer better rates for multiple locks at once
- Lock quality: Premium security locks cost more but provide enhanced protection
Beyond Door Locks: Other Locksmith Services
Our comprehensive service extends beyond standard door locks. Many Bellmore, NY residents don't realize that auto locksmith services follow similar principles. If you've experienced a car lockout or need a new vehicle key, we provide mobile solutions that come to you.
Our auto locksmith services include:
- Car key replacement using impressioning and decoding techniques
- Ignition repair and replacement for any make and model
- Transponder key programming for modern vehicles
- Emergency lockout assistance when you're locked out of your car
- Key extraction when keys break in car door or ignition cylinders
Quick Tips for Lock Maintenance
Regular lock maintenance extends the life of your hardware and prevents emergency situations. Here are simple steps every property owner should follow:
- Lubricate locks annually with graphite powder (never use oil)
- Test your keys regularly—if they stick, address it promptly
- Avoid the rubber band trick for stuck locks; call professionals instead
- Inspect locks for rust, especially on exterior doors exposed to weather
- Don't force keys that don't turn smoothly
- Keep a spare key in a secure location (not under the doormat!)
- Consider upgrading older locks every 7-10 years
Making Your Decision
The choice between rekeying and changing locks depends on your unique circumstances. If your locks function properly and you simply need to control access, rekeying is the practical, cost-effective solution. However, if your security hardware is outdated, damaged, or you want enhanced protection, full replacement is worth the investment.
Our experienced locksmith professionals can assess your situation and recommend the best approach. We serve residential and commercial customers throughout Bellmore, providing honest advice that prioritizes your security and budget.
Contact Bellmore Locksmith Today
Whether you need emergency lockout assistance, routine rekey service, or complete lock replacement, our team is ready to help. As a certified company serving the Bellmore community and surrounding Long Island areas, we pride ourselves on fast response times, quality workmanship, and customer satisfaction.
We offer 24 hour emergency service because lock and security issues don't wait for convenient business hours. From your home on Pine Dr to your business along Sunrise Hwy, we're just a phone call away.
Don't compromise on security or pay dealership prices for lock and key services. Call Bellmore Locksmith at (516) 895-6179 today to discuss your lock security needs, schedule an appointment, or request immediate emergency assistance. Our professionals are standing by to provide the solution you need at a price you can afford.

